16 Sims 4 Legacy Challenges You Need to Try
Legacy challenges in the Sims 4 are a fantastic way to add new life and structure to your gameplay!
These fun challenges are full of stories that take you through multiple generations, each filled with twists, goals, and plenty of Sim drama!
Whether you’re in the mood for some bromantic fun or something a bit more supernatural, I’ve put together this list to ensure there’s something for everyone.
Some challenges have clear rules and objectives, while others let you get creative and guide you to tell your own unique stories.
So, let’s find your new Sims 4 legacy challenge!
1. Legacy of Hearts
Inspired by the Lovestruck expansion pack, Legacy of Hearts explores all the different aspects of Sim love, romance and relationships! The goals for each heir focus on making connections and building their skills and lives around the provided storylines.
2. Ever After Legacy Challenge
The Ever After Legacy Challenge is a ten-generation challenge that provides you with fun story arcs for each new generation. This challenge is perfect if you want detailed narratives to follow while working toward the usual goals and requirements.
3. Astrology Legacy
The celestial-themed Astrology Legacy Challenge has ten generations, each inspired by a celestial object. From the Sun generation, which focuses on wealth and status, to the social connections and friendships of the Mercury generation, every heir has a unique set of characteristics, aspirations, and goals based on astrology.
4. The Family Dynamics Challenge
The Family Dynamics Challenge is a fun way to dive into the different relationships and dynamics of your Sim families. In this challenge, you play through different family scenarios, each with its own challenges and goals. Throughout the generations, you recreate a range of family relationships and explore the ups and downs of your heir’s family life!
5. The Bromance Legacy
Add a touch of bromance to The Sims with The Bromance Legacy challenge. This challenge focuses on building strong friendships between two male Sims that last through the generations as they raise their families and grow old alongside one another. This challenge is a fun way to explore the bonds of friendship rather than just focusing on family ties!
6. Whimsy Stories Challenge
The Whimsy Stories Legacy Challenge is a story-rich challenge with a unique set of narratives and goals. This challenge encourages you to delve deep into the lives of your Sims, offering engaging narratives to play through in each generation.

7. Supernatural Legacy Challenge
The Supernatural Legacy Challenge establishes a family lineage of supernatural beings, starting with vampires and ending with Imps. Not all of the supernatural creatures exist within the Sim world, which adds a little creativity to this challenge!
8. Career Legacy Challenge
The Career Legacy Challenge is a great way to explore the various career options that The Sims 4 has to offer! In each generation, your heir must successfully reach the top of a different career track and master the skills necessary to complete their career branch.
9. The Decades Challenge
The Decades Legacy Challenge is a journey through time as you play from the 1890s to the 2010s, with each generation representing a different decade. You must stick to each era’s rules and technological limitations while exploring that decade’s culture, fashion and significant events.
10. Lucid Legacy
The Lucid Legacy challenge is another challenge which offers unique stories for each generation. Each heir has a very different story from the one before, which helps keep things fresh, perfect for anyone who gets bored after playing a few generations.
11. Sims in Bloom
The Sims in Bloom Legacy Challenge is a nature-inspired challenge where each heir embodies the colours, traits, and personality of a specific flower. Play your way through careers, aspirations, and skills, all tied closely to each generation’s flower, from a cheerful gardener starting a lush legacy to a self-absorbed celebrity chasing fame!
12. Updated Differences in the Family Tree Challenge
If you’re in it for the long haul, the Differences in the Family Tree challenge can last up to thirty-six generations. This is because it gives you the chance to explore all the careers, skills and aspirations that The Sims and its expansion packs have to offer. It’s a great way to discover things you might not have tried before!
13. Seven Deadly Sims
The Seven Deadly Sins Legacy Challenge is a seven-generation challenge where each heir represents one of the deadly sins: wrath, greed, lust, envy, gluttony, sloth, or pride. This challenge is full of interesting stories and character development as each heir grapples with their sin and, throughout their lifetime, seeks redemption or change.
14. Not So Berry Legacy Challenge
The popular Not So Berry legacy challenge encourages you to explore different aspects of the game that you may not have played before. For example, the challenge includes tasks such as completing the elements and postcard collections. A specific colour represents each heir, allowing you to get really creative with your Sim’s style, hair, and outfits.

15. Elemental Legacy Challenge
If you fancy exploring some of The Sims’ expansion and game packs, the Elemental Legacy Challenge is the perfect way. Each generation in this challenge is themed not only on an element, such as fire or air, but also on a specific Sim pack.
16. Poison Garden Legacy
The Poison Garden Legacy is another challenge based on flowers, but this time, they’re poisonous! Each heir has a poisonous trait, and the toxic plant of that generation influences their goals. Each generation comes with suggested colours to use in your clothing and decor, or you can create berry sims instead!
Sims 4 Legacy Challenges
I hope you found your next legacy challenge to try! What’s your fave legacy challenge? Let me know in the comments!